NAVIGATION

A Tougher/Better/Best Sport?

Share

photo 1Recently a conversation online erupted after the question was brought up about comparing the difficulty and “toughness” of CrossFit vs. Ultra Running vs. Farm Chores vs. OCR. It was a lively conversation and today again I found myself talking to one of the trainers at the CrossFit affiliate I train having a very similar conversation.

 

Admit You Are Crazy

The first thing to acknowledge is people competing in most sports as adults are in one way or another “crazy”. Whether you like it or not if you care about a sport and compete at a competitive level as an adult people will probably call you crazy at one point or another. Whether you are in the gym 6-7 days a week, often twice a day or you hit the roads or trails prior to dawn to get your miles in, the truth is crazy can be translated to committed. Once you go above and beyond just the baseline fitness levels, you can put yourself in the crazy category. If you are actively training for competition, sorry to say you are in the crazy category.

 photo 2

It’s Not Harder It’s Just Different

Every sport has it’s difficulties, even the most mundane seeming. Sinking a 20ft put with a slopping green can be just as hard as overhead squating 2x’s your body weight and just as hard as running around in circles for 24 hours of obstacles. It’s just different not harder. If a competitive CrossFit athlete loses focus for a few seconds it could mean the difference between a win and not making top 15. The ultra runner needs to be able to sustain a level of concentration and constant feedback. The 5K runner needs to watch every step of his pacing. Just as the farmer needs to ensure his axe hits the wood in the right spot, otherwise they might loose a toe. None of these are easier than the other, just different.

 

photo 3

 

I constantly find people try to put down one method of fitness or training. Whereas each has it’s ups and downs. I think it’s wrong to tell the ultra runner that they don’t work as hard because they don’t go as fast as a marathoner. Or tell the CrossFit athlete that their training has no carry over into life. Truthfully, if someone is trying to better themselves and their fitness, embrace it. Be thankful they are working on becoming a better version of themselves, don’t hate the method. I find it close minded to say this or that athlete is not working out as intensely as another. Intensity comes in different forms and and we are all wired to react to different type of competition and training.

 

FARM WORK

Finally to set the record straight, farm work is still the original workout. If you want to experience what the original workouts were, just go to a farm and work the fields, feed the animals, chop wood, pull weeds, and harvest the crops. Now that truly is the original workout, or as our grandparents would say, a normal day.

work-farm

 

Women-lumberjacks-carrying-logs

What are your thoughts? Do you think one thing is more difficult than the rest?

Margaret Schlachter

About Margaret Schlachter

Margaret Schlachter is Founder of DirtinYourSkirt.com. She has been part of the OCR Community since 2010. When not working on the next article she can be found running from race-to-race. She is Editor-in-Chief of MudRunGuide.com. She authored the book Obstacle Race Training.
This entry was posted in Musings. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to A Tougher/Better/Best Sport?

  1. christian says:

    ah. yes.

    this comes up all the time.

    if you think about what’s “tough” or “harder” or “more challenging” I’m not sure that it’s anything we “like” to do. The two just don’t go together.

    Assuming you (proverbial “you”) don’t “like” this in the way that you like, say, running a Spartan Sprint, here’s a challenge:

    Next time it pouring down rain, and freezing cold, stop what you are doing, get into some gear tolerable for the conditions, and carry buckets of water up some hills for two hours straight…

    That’s “tough” and “challenging” cuz it sucks and you don’t want to do it.

    Showing up at marketed mud run, or OCR, or Ultra, or 5K, or whatever, isn’t all that “tough” — you knew what was coming, you knew mostly what to expect, you trained (hopefully) for the event, and mostly, you CHOSE to do as something you ENJOY.

    It happens, but its rare to find someone say, I really hate running, so I’m going to sign up for a 100-miler. Why? because they’d rather slit their throat than do an activity they hate for over 24 hours.

    Wanna be uber-tough? Trump all the disciplines, start choosing to activities you dislike, or suck at, and do them anyway.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Enter your email address to subscribe to posts:


  •   Hyper Vest SXY and FIT from Hyperwear.com
  • Instagram

    • Run 🏃🏻‍♀️ Fish 🎣Run 🏃🏻‍♀️
::
A different way to earn your dinner 🍴
::
🧔🏼🐾🐾
#utahhiking #runfishrun #headsweatsambassador #headsweats #keepacoolhead #familytime❤️ #weekendadventure #earnyourview #earnyourdinner #fishinggirls #americanforkcanyon #inov_8 #utahtrails #utahtrailrunning #utahtrailgirls #getoutsideandplay
    • More prototypes from @meanmugspotteryco - the same color glaze on each only one is a half dip and the other a full dip.
::
Half or Full?
::
Love sharing this process with the entire DIYS community!
::
#meanmugspottery #mugswithmeaning #prototypes #womenownedbusinesses #handmademugs #madeinutah #slc
    • The prototypes are in for the Dirt in Your Skirt mugs by @meanmugspotteryco
::
Weigh in and tell me what you think. Does one glaze stand out to you?
::
If you aren’t psyched about any let me know and we can try other glazed.
::
The women at Mean Mugs Pottery Co are awesome and so cool to work with. They let me stop by each step of the process and I will be documenting the production of the final product! And having them on the podcast.
::
But let me know what you think...
::
#handmademug #womensupportingwomen #womenownedbusiness #dirtinyourskirt #prototypes #meanmugs #mugswithmeaning #madewithpassion #womenhelpingwomenwin
    • The smiles that happen when you watch your kids (dogs in my case) completely enjoy nature, you redefine your company’s mission, and get some vitamin D.
::
All on a quick 6.5 mile run this morning after finishing up @mudrunguide and Other projects before 9am.
::
But mostly the smile is from learning how to get out and go for a run without the “not good enough” self talk, without chasing some race goal, making sure I am in the right HR zone, doing it because it was on a schedule or any of the other reasons I once hit the trails.
::
These days I am slow, walk when I want, don’t have a training goal, stop when it’s not fun and really get outside without any purpose - other than fun.
::
I spent over 20 years following training plans and chasing that next PR.
::
It’s been a hard learning process just to get out for no other reason or purpose than you want to be there and want to be outside. No GPS watch, no strava, no pr’s, just me, my dogs, and the mountains.
::
I think the smile says it all.
::
#runningwithdogs #headsweats #headsweatsambassador #keepacoolhead #trailtime #trailrunning #findyourbalance #findyourbliss #exploreconquerinspire #getoutside #utahtrails #utahtrailrunning #selfcaretime #findyoursmile
    • Eight years ago today my life would forever change, without me knowing it at the moment.
::
I headed off to this @spartan thing outside of Burlington, Vermont. I had just come out of a pretty dark time that included, losing my job and home in one conversation, a brush with a near DUI, and a complete mental collapse.
::
I picked myself up after having to move back home for a couple months, spent time volunteering, became a certified wilderness EMT, and took a hard look at my life.
::
By chance a friend had “liked” this new kind of race and brand called Spartan Race. On a whim I signed up, out of shape, and in search of something.
::
These photos are from that first Spartan Race on May 16, 2010. Crossing the finish line I knew I found something. Not knowing what that something was yet...
::
In the last eight years, my life has transformed. New job, new home, a husband, dogs, cat, book, countless articles written, mentioned in numerous publications, and the latest my podcast.
::
If I had told that semi-broken young woman what lay ahead she won’t have believed you. I don’t believe it some days.
::
While I might not have the largest bank accounts or most followers or any of that. I do have a wealth of experiences and friendship that are the most important things in life.
::
I have created and shaped a life I want to live and continue the journey of self-discovery while being able to help others.
::
My takeaway is the smallest decision can profoundly change your life if you let it.
::
My heart continues to be filled with humble gratitude for the abundance in my life. I am forever grateful for that first race and the people (many who are good friends today) who put on that crazy first event in 2010.
::
Oh and we can look back at the obstacles and giggle as we see the progression of the sport and the @spartanrace brand.
::
#spartan #spartanrace #mudrunguide #lifechangingmoments #lifechangingjourney #honorthemoment #spartans #obstacleracing #ocr #mudrun #wewerejustkids #funfirst #dosomethingnew #gratitude🙏
    • Went to the woods this afternoon with friends for some nature time with a little mushroom hunting on the side.
::
Came home with enough to share the spoils and enjoy a nice dinner.
::
Definitely an earn your meal afternoon in the woods!
::
#mushroomhunting #morels #morelseason #getoutside #foragedfood #forager #moveyourdna #stacking #utah #natureheals #naturetime #mountaintherapy #mountainviews #keepacoolhead #headsweatsambassador #headsweats #funwithfriends #utahhiking
    • Ever see those people who are 💯 themselves 💯 of the time and wonder how they do it?
::
Sarah Knight @mcsnugz is the international bestselling author of three books teaching you how to give less f*cks, get your sh*t together, and her latest is about you doing you unapologetically, and without people thinking you are a psycho in the process 😏
::
Such a fun episode to record and Sarah is a rockstar anti-guru who uses colorful language to distill rock solid information. Find it on your favorite player or the website, link in the profile.
::
#sarahknightauthor #sarahknightbooks #liveunapologetically #liveauthentically #givelessfucks #youdoyou #antiguru #womenleaders #femalepodcaster #podcasts #speakyourtruth #womenpodcast #womenpodcasters
    • Saying goodby sucks, but Puss Puss lived like a boss all the way to the end, capturing his last mouse just eight days ago.
::
This photo was taken yesterday by Forest as Puss Puss loved drinking out of the pond. We have him lots of love last night and let him go on his terms this morning completing the life/death cycle with grace.
::
Photo Credit: @sevenlovespirals
    • This woman! @barbwirequeenofgreen of @wired.4.life she has been a friend since we met in 2012 at @spartanrace Tuxedo. I have watched her journey and learned so much from her.
::
While we might not see each other very much the connections run deep and still forever grateful that she was the first person to be on the podcast.
::
Everyone needs a friend like Andi, while we might not chat on the phone for hours or see each other much we support the work of one another completely.
::
I cannot wait to see her continue to develop her painting classes and yoga instruction and keep that barrel full!
::
For Patreon supporter tomorrow I will have a special catchup we recorded before she had to head to the airport.
::
Because when women support other women we all collectively are raised up.
::
#friendship #utah #womenleaders #womeninleadership #speakyourtruth #podcasts #alltidesrise #supportoneanother #supportothers #multidimensional #spartanOG

    Follow Me!